Call Now: 800-288-5378
Three ways to get a free quote
~
InsuranceYourWay is all about choices
In food sometimes you cook, sometimes you pick from a menu, and sometimes you want a salad bar - now insurance can be like that with InsuranceYourWay.
About Us
~
The roots of Mitchell Insurance Inc run deep - not just before the internet or before cell phones or even before Color TV - we're talking about before the Civil War, automobiles, electricity or the nation of Germany... yep, that's old!
Old isn't always good, but when you sprinkle in a great experienced staff and modern InsurTech and the innovation that's driving our society you might just end up with something very special and unique. Think back stage passes to a laser light show at a European castle or the very best table at your favorite restaurant and the chef comes by to chat and brings you free apps and dessert.
​
We've combined our vast experience with some world-class insurance companies and their innovative technologies in one memorable website. Explore this website to learn more or even to buy some great products from some great carriers or visit www.Since1849.com to find out what we do when we're not playing on the internet.
​
Client Testimonials
Rich Wilson
Mitchell Insurance has been amazing in helping us acquire the RIGHT insurance for the needs of our Not for Profit. Bill went out of his way to make sure that it was all done in such a way that we are covered the way we needed to be. What a great company to work with. I cant recommend them high enough.
Brian Helfer
Mitchell Insurance, Inc. has been a great asset to my family and businesses since 1994. The owners and staff have constantly gone "out of their way" to provide critical industry knowledge, research and marketplace requirements to make sure we are addressing all scenarios and rates for our personal and business insurance coverage's. Here, we are not just a policy number and they are not just an insurance broker, they are my partner in securing our family and business endeavors year-round. Hope you will feel the same way !!
Kelly Nutt
I have worked with Tracy Mitchell for over 5 years. She has went above and beyond to meet all of our business insurance needs and questions. Tracy is extremely knowledgeable is all aspects of insurance. Mitchell Insurance is a trustworthy risk advisor and their services well exceed all expectations.
Some of our Featured Products
~
Special Events
Event Planners
Photographers
Races
Parties
Fundraisers
Weddings
Musicians
and many more
​
Short term Liability for:
Contractors
Vendors
Daily rates / turn on and off as needed
​
Workers' Compensation:
46 States
100's of business types
Contact us
~
Email & Phone:
Address
Mitchell Insurance, Inc.
400 N Main St.
P O Box 788
Butler, PA 16001